Link to main version

67

The New Supreme Judicial Council Faces a Test of Its Independence

Judge Neli Kutsкова and Prosecutor Vladimir Nikolov outlined the key tasks facing the new body and warned of the risk of political dependencies

Снимка: БГНЕС
ФАКТИ публикува мнения с широк спектър от гледни точки, за да насърчава конструктивни дебати.

The election of the new Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) has concluded after a prolonged period during which the previous council operated with an expired mandate. Following the latest vote in the professional quota, the body is now fully staffed and is set to begin work with 25 members – 11 representatives of the professional quota, 11 of the parliamentary quota and three ex officio members: the Prosecutor General and the presidents of the Supreme Court of Cassation and the Supreme Administrative Court.

The last vacant seat was filled by investigator Petko Petkov, who received 323 votes against 40 for Boyko Atanasov. Atanasov has a seven-day period in which he can challenge the result. If no appeal is filed, the names of the newly elected members must be published in the “State Gazette”.

The first test will be the election of a Prosecutor General

Among the most important tasks facing the new SJC is the election of a permanent Prosecutor General. The post has had no permanent holder since the removal of Ivan Geshev in 2023. The council also faces the procedure for electing a director of the National Investigation Service.

Prosecutor Vladimir Nikolov, who was a candidate for membership of the SJC, said that the election of a Prosecutor General would largely determine the assessment of the council’s entire mandate. “We need a person who understands and bears responsibility for the enormous leadership, managerial, legal and administrative power that this position carries. A person who is able to recognise this power and, if you will, to restrain it,” Nikolov told NOVA.

Cautious optimism and a warning about dependencies

Judge Neli Kutsкова described the hearings and the election of the new judicial officials as grounds for cautious optimism. She stressed that the council’s main test would be its ability to withstand political pressure.

“Politicians’ job is to determine the policies of the state. But it is extremely harmful when politicians begin interfering in the so-called appointment of personnel,” Neli Kutsкова said.

According to her, there has been a breakthrough involving free-thinking magistrates among the representatives of the prosecutors’ quota. Kutsкова warned that political support for a given candidate must not turn into subsequent dependency. “It is always very important to elect people with backbone,” she said.

Nikolov also said that there were respectable professionals among those elected, but that their independence would only now be put to the test. He did not rule out attempts by people who had held senior positions in the prosecution service to retain influence through the council’s new members, but declined to name specific individuals. “You will know them by their deeds,” the prosecutor commented.

Expectations for the investigations into the “Euro” and “Notary” cases

Kutsкова expects the new SJC to complete the investigations into the influence networks linked to Petar Petrov – Pepi the Euro, and Martin Bozhanov – the Notary. In her view, society must receive a clear answer as to what has been established in these cases and whether similar dependencies also exist at the local level.

Nikolov described the election of the new body as a step in the right direction and criticised the previous SJC: “We saw the epitome of what the council should not represent.” The new judicial officials must now demonstrate through their decisions whether they will impose a different model of governance for the judicial system.

Sources: nova.bg